Rating: 4/5 Stars
Genre: Graphic Novel/Historical/Mythology
Release Date: 10/12/2010
Add to Goodreads
About the Book: Homer's epic poem about Odysseus trying to return home after the Trojan War transferred into a graphic novel format.
GreenBeanTeenQueen Says: I had to seek this one out and read it after The Odyssey knocked out my pick One Crazy Summer in SLJ's Battle of the Kids Books. I mean, how could something beat out my pick, One Crazy Summer?? I had to know!
It's an impressive undertaking to transfer this poem into a graphic novel format. Some might think because it's a graphic novel it would be easier to read, which isn't the case at all. It's still a very dense book with a lot of detail and a lot of story. It's also not toned down at all for young readers. I think it's easy to say, oh this is The Odyssey, so we can hand this over to Percy Jackson fans! But this is not the lighthearted, funny story of Percy. This is The Odyssey, complete with gore, fighting, blood, backstabbing, sex, betrayal, and death. Sure, some fans will enjoy it, but it's not an easy read and though both stories deal with Greek Mythology, they are very different.
For the most part I enjoyed the graphic novel, although the ending where there was blood all over the palace and suitors speared everywhere was a bit gross. (Like I said, it is very gory and I'm a chicken when it comes to gore!!) But the way the author kept true to the story and almost brought it to life through the illustrations is quite impressive. He also had to pare down the text so it would fit within the confines the graphic novel panels. I don't think he lost the meaning or the beauty of the poem and the art and text work together well to tell the whole story.
I do think it would be interesting to use this version in the classroom so readers can have a visual element to go along with the text. I think a lot of readers would respond to the story even more if they had both. An excellent graphic novel and a fantastic version of a classic story, Gareth Hinds version of The Odyssey is worth checking out.
I have to add my side tangent about The Odyssey. I always get annoyed at Odysseus. He goes off and cheats on Penelope with various goddesses, because you know, he was under a spell and all, and Penelope stays and home and fights off the advances of many suitors-for 17 years. Doesn't really seem all that fair if you ask me! But hey, the book is still good, even with my gripes!:)